Review! The School for Good and Evil books 1&2 by Soman Chainani


goodevil1The School for Good and Evil

By Soman Chainani

Illustrated by  Iacopo Bruno

512 pages – ages 12+
Published by HarperCollins on April 15, 2014 (reprint) Originally published in 2013

Summary– Agatha and Sophie. Best friends. Polar opposites. Everyone believes that Sophie, who is beautiful and loves pink, will be chosen to go to the mystic School for Good and Evil, specifically the Good School. Agatha, who wears black, unshapely dresses, and has dark, misshapen hair, is expected for the School for Evil. But what happens when Sophie gets put into the School for Evil, and Agatha – the School for Good?

What I thought– This is a great book about how looks can be deceiving. Sophie and Agatha are really great, realistic characters, who you really route for, although, I knew at once that Sophie would really be Evil (her state of mind in her old town kind of set me up for it). With this story, Mr. Chainani really prompts deeper thinking about what is really good and what is really evil. I like how the characters develop in the story and Sophie and Agatha decide who they really are and what is really important in their lives. The ideas of the schools for good and evil is cool. I like that it is where fairytale characters get their “training.”  I also like how it references common fairytales (or not so common), as in that some of the characters are related to the main characters from the fairytales (someone is the daughter of the Sheriff of Nottingham (Robin Hood), for example). This book is a marvelous debut from Soman Chainani! It kept me up at night reading **Oops. Sorry Mom! 😉 ** It is very well written, and is quite funny! The black and white illustrations are a great touch.

goodevil2School for Good & Evil: A World Without Princes

School for Good and Evil (Book 2)

By Soman Chainani

Illustrated by Iacopo Bruno

448 pages ages 12+
Published by HarperCollins on April 15, 2014

Summary- All is well. Sophie and Agatha are back in their hometown. When Agatha accidentally wishes for a boy she fell in love with, she and Sophie get drawn back into the world of the School. Only to be completely befuddled. Upon their return, they find out that there is no School for Good and Evil anymore. Now it is just the School for Girls and Boys! After what happened in the last book, all of the princesses and witches realized that they didn’t need princes to have a happy ending, and the boys were kicked out, taking refuge in the Evil School. The Princes (and warlocks) are out for revenge, and with Sophie apparently on the verge of becoming a full-blown witch again, Agatha has her hands full! And don’t forget the mysterious new Dean Evelyn Sader who seems to be hiding something…

What I thought- This is a magnificent sequel to The School for Good and Evil. It captures all of the greatness from the last book, plus more! I love the chaos created when the schools are split. All the girls realized they don’t need princes, but do they? I also like the twist in the book about who is really behind all the decisions at the schools. There is a cool back story there too. This book has the perfect amount of drama and mystery in it, creating the feeling of hopeless despair, and the need for a resolution. Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t think the story was depressing, but it really made you feel for the characters! It kept me hooked – so much, that I couldn’t put it down, and stayed up past my bedtime to finish it. **Yup. Again, Mom. Sorry.** The ending sets it up for another book, which I hope will happen. I can really see this series as a movie (and yipee! I read on the official website that they are making it into a movie – I hope it is as good as the books!). The black and white illustrations, again, are a great addition to the story!

I am really enjoying this series!

Five out of five bookworms fivebooks

Want to learn more? Check out the official School for Good and Evil website HERE!

Categories: Age 12+

Tags: ,

10 replies

  1. Hmmmm…I am very intrigued. These might be Christmas reads for me.

    Say, Erik, Tuesday I put in a request for both “The Fourteenth Goldfish” and “Fantasy League” through the co-op our library is part of. It usually takes a week or two to get them, but I got an email that afternoon saying they were ready for me. It seems my local library had just purchased both books and processed that very day! And I requested them both. What are the odds? You are definitely on the cutting edge, my friend. 🙂

  2. These sound very interesting. I’ll have to check them out. Thanks Erik!

  3. What a great twist! Just when you think a plot like this must have been done before there are new ideas out there. Great reviews Erik!

  4. Mom surely wants to read these. She says she knows which school I would go to. I think she means…. Good…?

    Love and licks,

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: